The bad comment

A restaurant deleted one bad comment and got five more. How to reply to criticism calmly and publicly so it works in your favour.

By the Glide team. 2 min read

A waiter at a table in a dimly lit restaurant

They deleted one bad comment. They got five new ones.

Hi.

A restaurant in Veliko Tarnovo. Friday night, full house, the kitchen running late. One customer waited 50 minutes for her main course. At home, she wrote a comment under the restaurant’s latest post:

“We waited almost an hour for a moussaka. Nobody apologised. We won’t be coming back.”

The manager saw it on Saturday morning. He got angry. He deleted it. And he blocked the customer.

She had taken a screenshot before it was deleted. She posted it in a big local group: “Restaurant X deletes criticism and blocks its customers.”

By evening, her post had 140 comments. Five of them were from people telling their own bad experiences with the restaurant. Some old, some made up.

One comment about a 50-minute wait had turned into a reputation problem.

“What should I have done?” the manager asks.

“Replied. Calmly. Publicly.”

When someone writes a bad comment, they’re not just talking to you. They’re talking in front of everyone who will read it. And those people look less at the comment than at how you respond.

Deleting says: “We have something to hide.” A calm reply says: “We hear you, and we care.”

We wrote a reply in the group, on behalf of the restaurant:

“Hello, Maria. You’re right. On Friday night the kitchen was very late, and we should have apologised to you there and then. We didn’t, and we’re sorry. We also shouldn’t have deleted your comment; that was a mistake. We’ll message you privately. We’d like to invite you back, on us.”

We messaged her privately. She came with her husband two weeks later. Afterwards she wrote a new comment. A nice one.

Here’s how to reply to a bad comment:

  • Don’t delete and don’t block. Unless it’s an insult, spam or a lie. Everything else deserves a reply.
  • Wait until you’ve calmed down. Half an hour. Don’t reply angry.
  • Reply publicly, briefly and calmly. Say thank you, admit what’s true, apologise if there’s something to apologise for.
  • Move the conversation to private messages. “We’ll message you” or “call us on...”. The details aren’t for everyone to see.
  • Fix the cause. If the kitchen is late every Friday, the problem isn’t the comment.

Talk soon!

P.S. If you have a comment you don’t know how to answer, write to me. I’ll help you write a reply that doesn’t add fuel to the fire.

P.P.S. The moussaka now comes out in 20 minutes, even on Fridays. The customer who waited 50 now orders it every time. She says she wants to check it’s true.

More on social media