The reviews from Ivan I.

Made-up reviews don’t sell. How to collect real reviews from your customers with one short message.

By the Glide team. 2 min read

Yellow sticky notes with handwritten words on a wall

The website had twelve reviews.

All of them were written by the same person. And that person was the owner.

The company made kitchens to order. Good kitchens. I saw the photos of finished projects and they really were beautiful. The owner called me in because “people come to the website, but somehow they don’t trust us”.

I started looking around. I got to the reviews section.

“Amazing service!!! Highly recommend!!! – Ivan I.”

“The best kitchens in town!!! – Maria P.”

“Fast, quality, professional!!! – Petar G.”

And so on, twelve times. All with three exclamation marks. All with an initial instead of a surname. All sounding like one person who was very excited and in a big hurry.

And the last review ended with “I’m proud of you!”.

“Who wrote this one?” I ask.

A pause.

“My mother.”

It turned out that customers “don’t want to write”, so the owner had written the reviews himself. His intentions were good. “But they really are happy, I just wrote it for them.”

I understand him. But people aren’t stupid. When they see twelve identical reviews with three exclamation marks, they don’t think “wow, so many happy customers”. They think “he wrote these himself”. And if he wrote them himself, what else is he hiding?

A real review looks different. It has details. It has small imperfections. It has something only a real customer would write.

We made a simple plan. After every fitting, the owner sends the customer a short message with a link straight to the Google reviews. And one question: “What worried you before we started, and how did it turn out?”

In two months he collected 23 real reviews.

One of them said: “They were a day late with the fitting, but they admitted it, apologised and fixed a door that we had knocked, without charging us.”

That review sold more kitchens than all twelve “Amazing!!!” put together. Because it sounded like a real person. Because it showed what happens when something goes wrong.

Here’s how to collect real reviews:

  • Ask right after you finish the job. That’s when the customer is happiest. A month later they’ve forgotten.
  • Make it easy. One link, one tap. Nobody is going to look for where to write to you on their own.
  • Ask a specific question. “Leave a review” leads to “Everything was great”. “What worried you before?” leads to stories.
  • Don’t be scared of imperfect reviews. A review with one small criticism looks more real than ten perfect ones.
  • Never make them up. Not you, and not your mother.

Talk soon!

P.S. If you have happy customers but there isn’t a single review on your website, write to me. I’ll help you come up with a message people actually reply to.

P.P.S. Ivan I. exists, it turns out. He’s his cousin. His kitchen is very nice, but the review has been taken down.

More on web design